Voluntourism: A Focus on Faces

I’ve selected some photos I took during two trips to Nicaragua in 2010 and 2011 with a volunteer group from my high school. Travel with a focus on humanitarian work has become increasingly popular in recent decades, especially among students, and images of children living in poverty in underdeveloped countries are often used to encourage volunteering or solicit donations to humanitarian projects. Criticism of the manipulative nature of such images, which are meant to appeal to the audience’s emotions and elicit sympathy, is prompted in We Need New Names, when Darling and her friends pose for the photographers from the NGO, and by photo exhibits like the one from the Salvadoran Civil War we looked at in class. For one thing, there’s the question of the ethics of taking photographs without necessarily asking the subjects’ permission or giving them any control over how the images are used or distributed. Furthermore, our discussion of cosmopolitanism and the way it is tied up with privilege made me think about the larger question of the trips themselves, and whether they focus more on the volunteers’ experience than on the people who are supposed to benefit from the work being done. In a way, these pictures are nothing more than souvenirs; after nine days of building houses and distributing clothing donations, I was able to come back to the U.S., take a hot shower, and get on with my life without ever having asked these children’s names.

-Sophie

27212_1357011131718_544612_n27212_1357007971639_1686311_n  27212_1357011331723_4054783_n184324_1886197481046_7826682_n189558_1886182960683_328245_n   27212_1357010931713_7650494_n

One thought on “Voluntourism: A Focus on Faces”

  1. I agree that “volunteerism” has become almost commonplace among young people in recent years, whether for better or worse. Of course, any exposure to a different culture is probably better than none, and volunteering one’s time is usually beneficial despite the motivating reasons. Yet, oftentimes these “service” excursions contribute very little to either the communities they are supposed to be helping or to the individual’s cultural awareness. Many young people visit other countries in large groups where they have projects scheduled for short periods of time. When these volunteer groups visit these places, however, they may have little understanding of the local culture or the effects their project will have on the community. Then, after their short stay, they will leave with not much more knowledge about the culture than they started with. Oftentimes, building a school or donating supplies may seem helpful, but in order for them to be effective, they must have the proper foundation and coordination that usually takes much more time and effort. Of course, volunteerism may be beneficial in many cases, yet projects and service must be thought of in the long term rather than the short term. The individuals themselves would also gain more from experiences abroad if they first dedicate time to educating themselves about the culture, for without the proper understanding, volunteerism will remain ineffective and unenlightening.

    Audrey

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s