Reluctant Fundamentalist Reflection

9/11 changes everything for Changez, the ambitious protagonist of Mohsin Hamid’s Reluctant Fundamentalist. Soon after the towers fall, Changez’ world begins to deteriorate. His relationship with Erica, a beautiful and rich American, unravels and his focus moves away from the “fundamentals” and toward the new and terrifying global landscape. As shown throughout the text, Changez’s impressive suit and well-paying job are unable shield him from anti-Muslim bigotry. In the wake of 9/11, it seems that Changez is always being harassed. When working in New Jersey, his possessions are stolen and his car is ravaged. Changez’s skin and religion have become a liability in this new world order.

When speaking about these changes, Changez uses the language of a conquered person. His tone becomes accusatory as he relays this experience to his American guest: “Your country’s flag invaded New York after the attacks. It was everywhere”(Hamid 38). From this one line, it becomes very clear that Changez has mentally separated New York from America. For Changez, New York is its own nation—socially and politically distinct from the rest of the country. Thus, the proliferation of the American flag across the New York landscape feels like an invasion. “They [The flags] all seemed to proclaim: We are America, Not New York,”says Changez (Hamid 38). The place where Changez had felt at home suddenly became American; thus, inhospitable to the multiculturalism and cosmopolitanism he associated with New York.

Changez’s relationship with Erica  parallels his relationship with the United States. At first infatuated, Changez comes to recognize the dark underbelly beneath the shiny exterior. In the text, Erica’s dangerous nostalgia is compared to America’s post 9/11 nostalgia.

“There was something undeniably retro about the flags and uniforms, about generals addressing cameras in war rooms              and newspaper headlines featuring such words as duty and honor. I had always though of America as a nation that                    looked forward; for the first time, I was struck by its determination to look back” (Mohsin 53).

The reader witnesses the gradual degeneration of Changez’s American dream. For Changez, America was supposed to be about the future. That is what his boss Jim always pointed toward.Yet, Changez views Americans pining for times that shouldn’t necessarily be exalted. He questions whether America should try to replicate the unquestioned dominance and safety that marked its past. As he soon realizes, the past being romanticized does not include or care for a Muslim immigrant originally hailing from Pakistan.

As Changez becomes increasingly disillusioned with the United States, his attention becomes squarely focused on his homeland. During his last assignment in Chile, he barely expends any effort, leaving his superior to do all of the work alone. A conversation with Chilean Native Juan-Bautista acts as the final nail in the coffin. This conversation leads Changez to realize that his talents and energies should be used to benefit his true homeland instead of America, which has become foreign and strange to him. The crumbling of Changez’s American dream paves the way for a new dream and life in Pakistan.

By Kailyn Amory

One thought on “Reluctant Fundamentalist Reflection”

  1. I think it is really interesting to consider the relationship between Changez and Jim. Jim is in many ways an embodiment of the American Dream – someone who gains a top position and is financially successful due to talent and hard work, not family wealth or connections. This is interesting, because it suggests that in this novel, the American Dream is not entirely seen as unachievable fiction, at least on an individual level.

    Initially, it could be argued that Changez also achieves the American Dream, because he becomes very successful at Underwood Samson. However, 9/11 and his realization of his position as something akin to a janissary disrupts this. I think that it is possible that this suggests that while for some people the American Dream might be possible, it involves giving up or erasing your background to do so. This suggests that if immigrants want a chance at the American Dream, they must assimilate fully, erasing their heritage, and even then if an event draws attention to their cultural identities, then even attempting to fully assimilate may not be enough.

    – Tanya


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s